spot_img
Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Op-Ed: New Jersey’s Data Center Moratorium: Regulating First, Asking Questions Later 

A moratorium in search of a problem 

In September, Assemblywoman Annette Quijano introduced Bill A5482, a six-month moratorium on the development of data centers using more than 10 megawatts. It followed a summer of social media campaigns and town-hall protests, not a single study. 

Worse, the bill creates a commission to gather the facts only after the pause begins. That is governing by petition: pander first, study later. Before passing another regulation, lawmakers should do their jobs and find out what problems data centers have actually caused, measure them and fix what needs fixing. I doubt they find much. 

20 years without a crisis 

New Jersey has hosted data centers for more than two decades; Equinix opened in Secaucus in 2002. While reports vary, state officials say roughly 80 operate here while other sites tracking this information say that number is about 55 facilities. By comparison, Virginia has nearly 400 operating data centers and Texas about 300, with hundreds more planned in each, according to a Pew Research Center analysis. 

By and large, the facilities in New Jersey run Wall Street trading, bank records, hospital systems and the phone in your pocket. In 20 years, nobody has blamed them for blackouts or empty reservoirs. Why the sudden alarm? 

So what’s the problem? 

If lawmakers want to find the problem before fixing it, the three fears raised most often – power, water and noise – are good places to start. None holds up in New Jersey.

We are not running out of power. 

Data centers represent just a fraction of New Jersey’s electricity usage. PSE&G’s own September 2026 filing with PJM, the regional grid operator, shows its 40 data center sites peak at 297 megawatts, a load that has barely moved since 2024. That is only about 3% of the state’s 2024 consumption, based on U.S. Energy Information Administration data. So they are clearly not sapping power. By comparison, data centers in Virginia account for 25% of all the electric demand in the Commonwealth, according to the Electric Power Research Institute. 

Yes, electricity bills jumped about 20% in 2025. But that came from PJM’s 13-state capacity auction, which a New Jersey moratorium would not touch. 

The water scare comes from the desert. 

Water fears come from giant AI campuses in hot, dry states, which rely on evaporative cooling and already limited aquifers. New Jersey’s cool months allow “free cooling” with outside air, and our humid summers make evaporative cooling inefficient. So facilities here commonly use closed-loop systems that recirculate their water. In 20 years, no one in New Jersey has complained that they have run out of water; certainly not from data centers. 

Noise rules are already on the books. 

New Jersey has regulated noise statewide since the 1970s. DEP rules, N.J.A.C. 7:29, cap any commercial or industrial facility at 65 decibels by day and 50 at night at a neighboring home’s property line, data centers included. That’s a sound level about as loud as a quiet suburban street. Virginia and Texas, the two biggest markets, have no comparable statewide limit. 

The users are banks and brokers, not AI factories. 

Most of New Jersey’s data centers have nothing to do with AI. Our review of state property tax records matched 37 operating facilities: 25 colocation centers serving banks, brokers and carriers; seven corporate sites for Barclays, BNY Mellon, Morgan Stanley, JPMorgan Chase, UBS and Verizon; and five others.  

The true AI projects, CoreWeave in Kenilworth and DataOne in Vineland, can be counted on one hand. When DataOne ran unpermitted generators, the DEP fined it $1.07 million. The existing rules worked without a moratorium. 

Ratables towns can’t afford to lose 

According to our analysis of state tax records and 2025 tax rates, the 37 operating facilities carry $2.43 billion in assessed value and pay an estimated $57 million a year in local property taxes. Piscataway alone collects about $17.5 million. 

That is a floor: it excludes PILOT payments, unchecked sites and untaxed equipment. And data centers add no students to local schools. Block that tax base, and homeowners or state school aid will have to make up the difference. Homeowners won’t like making up $57 million a year in compromised tax ratables and let’s face it, the State budget can’t afford it either! 

Expensive power already keeps the market small 

Power in New Jersey is expensive, which already keeps our data center market small. The EIA ranks our 2024 retail price 40th of 51, at 16.29 cents per kilowatt-hour, against 10.62 cents in Virginia and 9.79 cents in Texas. 

Developers do this math, which is why the boom is in Texas and Virginia. There is no gold rush here that needs stopping. 

Governor Sherrill should keep her promise 

Governor Sherrill promised to cut red tape, signing a permitting executive order on her first day. Her own data center rules, putting large users on their own electric rate, rewarding those that add their own power, and requiring them to report energy and water use, became law this summer. 

Those rules have not had time to work. Piling a moratorium on top, before anyone measures anything, is exactly the reflex she promised to break. Lawmakers who pander to the loudest voices, who are missing facts and motivated by emotion, should do the work instead: assess and quantify, then act. The governor should reject A5482.  

By Eugene Diaz, principal partner, Prism Capital Partners  

+ posts

Get the Latest News

Sign up to get all the latest news, offers and special announcements.

Get our Print Edition

All the latest updates, delivered.

Latest Posts

Get the Latest News

Sign up to get all the latest news, offers and special announcements.

Get our Print Edition

All the latest updates, delivered.