spot_img
Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Former governors see strong start for Sherrill, praise affordability and business agenda

A bipartisan panel of former governors largely defended Sherrill's handling of the Caldwell controversy and reflected on the realities of governing New Jersey.

Former New Jersey governors from both parties gave Gov. Mikie Sherrill generally high marks Wednesday during a panel at the New Jersey League of Municipalities Convention, while noting it remains early in her tenure.

Democrat Jon Corzine, who served from 2006 to 2010, graded Sherrill “in the A territory.” Former Governor James McGreevey gave her an A-, while former Governor Donald DeFrancesco awarded a B. Former acting Governor John Bennett declined to assign a grade, saying it was too early.

The four largely praised Sherrill’s handling of the Dale Caldwell controversy, her focus on affordability and business issues, and her ability to navigate Trenton’s political landscape. They also reflected on lessons they learned during their own time in office.

Bennett, who was acting governor for four days in 2002, said Sherrill’s record so far includes both strengths and weaknesses and described the Caldwell controversy as a “hiccup” for her. He also said he disagreed with her intervention in the federal operation of the Delaney Hall immigration detention center in Newark. On a positive note, he credited the governor with her work on affordability and business friendliness.

“She talks about the affordability. She talks about housing. These are things that we need in New Jersey and they’re very, very important,” Bennett said. “She wants to make the state more friendly to business. I think everyone that’s in state government has tried to do that. But in fairness, she signed that executive order to improve the New Jersey bottom of the barrel business climate. I think that is a plus.”

McGreevey said that just because a governor faces challenges doesn’t automatically mean it’s a mark against them. “Challenges are part of governance,” he said. “My sense is the governor handled it appropriately, compassionately, and intelligently, and resolved the issue and moved government forward.”

DeFrancisco said he doesn’t think Sherrill needed to conduct an investigation. “He should have just stepped down. I think it’s as simple as that,” DeFrancisco said.

Corzine said one of the biggest surprises he encountered upon taking office was discovering that New Jersey’s governor was not as powerful as the job’s constitutional authority suggested. “I thought it was the most powerful position constitutionally in the country, and I found out pretty quick it wasn’t,” he said.

Corzine recalled clashes with lawmakers over judicial nominations and budget proposals, saying he learned that “your own party may be your biggest enemy.” He said Sherrill has done a better job navigating those relationships than he did.

“I’m kind of a fan boy,” he said.

Asked about the challenges of governing, DeFrancesco said he had it a little easier because he served simultaneously as governor and Senate president. What he found most difficult was the demands of day to day and of communicating with the public.

On their proudest moments, DeFrancisco said it was dealing with the 9/11 tragedy. Bennett said it was dealing with environmental issues, while Corzine said it was work on social issues like community health clinics and child welfare. McGreevey said he was proud of New Jersey’s Highlands Water Protection and Planning Act, which sought to regulate development and safeguard drinking water across roughly 859,000 acres in northern New Jersey; and of reforms to motor vehicles and child protection services.

Bennett said governors succeed when they focus on the job at hand and cautioned Sherrill against seeking federal aspirations while still in state office. Sherrill, a first-term Democrat, took office in January.

“Some people have had those federal thoughts once they get into Trenton and they think the next step is to be in the White House,” Bennett said. “We need to focus on New Jersey.”

+ posts

Get the Latest News

Sign up to get all the latest news, offers and special announcements.

Get our Print Edition

All the latest updates, delivered.

Latest Posts

Get the Latest News

Sign up to get all the latest news, offers and special announcements.

Get our Print Edition

All the latest updates, delivered.