Horizon says its purchase of Summit Health could keep as much as $2.5 billion to $3 billion in added costs out of New Jersey’s health care market over the next five years.
The buyer is Horizon Mutual Holdings, the not-for-profit holding company set up under a 2020 state law, not Horizon Blue Cross Blue Shield of New Jersey, the regulated insurer.
The figures come from an analysis Horizon shared with BINJE. The deal, which is expected to top $1 billion, covers Summit Health’s New Jersey operations, including its CityMD sites, and is still subject to regulatory review.
Horizon’s argument is simple: Keep the same doctors in the same lower-cost settings, and the bills stay lower.
Dr. Nicole Henry-Dindial, a Summit Health family medicine physician and president of the Medical Society of New Jersey, made the same point in an interview with BINJE earlier this month. She noted she was speaking as a Summit doctor, not in her MSNJ role.
“If we can do hip replacements and colonoscopies in an ambulatory surgery center, where the cost of care is significantly lower, shouldn’t we?” she said.
According to Horizon, the savings would come from two places.
First, Summit’s physicians would keep billing at physician-practice rates rather than the higher hospital rates that typically kick in when a hospital system owns a practice.
Second, more procedures would move to freestanding surgery centers. Horizon said hospital outpatient departments charge 40% to 50% more than those centers for orthopedic and GI procedures.
Horizon’s numbers compare what the same doctors would cost under its ownership with what they would cost under a hospital system. It estimates the costs avoided over five years at:
- About $250 million to $300 million for the State Health Benefits Program, starting at roughly $55 million in the first year and climbing to about $64 million a year by 2031;
- About $1.2 billion to $1.6 billion for Horizon members, including individuals, small and large employers, municipalities and the SHBP;
- About $2.5 billion to $3 billion for all commercially insured New Jerseyans.
Horizon said much of that lands with its own members because it is already Summit’s biggest payer. It covers about 42% of Summit’s commercial revenue, compared with about 23% for the next-largest payer.
National research points the same way. A November 2025 National Bureau of Economic Research study found physician prices rose 15.1% within two years of a hospital buying the practice, with no measurable change in quality. A September 2025 report from the U.S. Government Accountability Office found at least 47% of doctors were employed by or affiliated with hospital systems in 2024, up from under 30% in 2012, and that the consolidation pushed up prices and spending while quality held steady or slipped.
The insurer also made four promises about how Summit would operate under its ownership:
- Summit keeps its own CEO, COO and management team, separate from the regulated insurer;
- The roughly one million New Jerseyans who see a Summit doctor or visit a CityMD in the state keep the doctors they chose, and those doctors direct their care;
- Summit physicians keep working with every hospital and every insurer in the state;
- More cases move to freestanding centers instead of hospital outpatient departments.
Horizon underscored its record in the Medicaid and Affordable Care Act markets, noting that it continued offering plans even when the economics were challenging — a commitment, it said, reflects its focus on keeping health care accessible in New Jersey.


